Related Experiment Video
Updated: Feb 9, 2026

Assessment of Mouse Judgment Bias through an Olfactory Digging Task
Published on: March 4, 2022
Conformational bias imposed by source microseeds results in structural ambiguity
Netanel Tzarum1, David Engelberg, Oded Livnah
1The Wolfson Centre for Applied Structural Biology, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Jerusalem, Israel.
Abstract:
The p38 MAP kinase pathway is an essential component of numerous cellular signalling networks which are usually activated in response to extracellular environmental stress conditions. In addition to the canonical activation, several alternative activation pathways have been identified for p38; one of these, in which p38 is initially phosphorylated on Tyr323 and consequently autoactivated, is exclusive to T cells and is induced by TCR activation. Intrinsically active and inactive mutants at position 323 have been developed in order to evaluate the structural changes that occur upon TCR-induced activation. In order to promote crystal growth, cross streak-seeding techniques were utilized. This technique has gained popularity in promoting crystal growth when spontaneous nucleation induces critical defects or is being entirely hindered. The crystal characteristics of some mutants were highly similar to those of the wild-type source seeds (form A). In contrast, other mutants crystallized spontaneously with a different space group and molecular packing (form B). One of the active mutants (Y323T) crystallized in both crystal forms, displaying different packing characteristics and significant differences in molecular conformation that were clearly dictated by the source seeds. This implies that the source seeds used in cross streak-seeding could, in some cases, impose bias on the structural outcome of the studied molecule. Such incidents could occur when the conformational freedom permits crystal packing while not reflecting the authentic structure.
Insights
The p38 MAP kinase pathway
Area of Science:
- Cellular signaling
- Molecular biology
- Structural biology
Background:
- The p38 MAP kinase pathway is crucial for cellular responses to environmental stress.
- Alternative activation pathways exist, including a T cell-specific pathway involving TCR activation and Tyr323 phosphorylation.
- Understanding these pathways is vital for immunology and drug development.
Purpose of the Study:
- To investigate structural changes in p38 MAP kinase during T cell-specific activation.
- To evaluate the impact of specific mutations on p38 conformation and autoactivation.
- To assess the influence of cross streak-seeding techniques on protein crystallization outcomes.
Main Methods:
- Site-directed mutagenesis to create active and inactive p38 mutants at Tyr323.
- Cross streak-seeding techniques to promote crystal growth.
- X-ray crystallography to determine the structures of wild-type and mutant p38.
Main Results:
- Mutants exhibited varying crystal characteristics, with some adopting the wild-type crystal form (A) and others forming a new form (B).
- The Y323T mutant crystallized in both forms, revealing distinct molecular conformations dictated by the seeding crystals.
- Cross streak-seeding can influence the observed molecular structure, potentially introducing bias.
Conclusions:
- The source seeds used in cross streak-seeding can impose conformational bias on crystallization outcomes.
- This phenomenon may lead to crystal structures that do not accurately represent the molecule's authentic conformation.
- Careful consideration of seeding methods is necessary for accurate structural determination in crystallography.
More Related Videos
Related Concept Videos
Correspondence Bias
Conformity
Confirmation Biases
Hindsight Biases
Bias
In statistics, a sampling bias is created when a sample is collected from a population, and some members of the population are not as likely to be chosen as others (remember, each member...
Conformations of Butane

