Loss-of-function mutation in a repressor module of human-specifically activated enhancer HACNS1

The cis-regulatory element contributed to gaining humanness is of great interest in human evolutionary studies. A human-accelerated region exceeding neutral evolutionary rates, termed HACNS1, was recently reported as a positively selected sequence acquiring novel TF-binding sites responsible for human-specific gain of limb enhancer function. However, another possibility is loss of function in repressor element in HACNS1. Signature of the human substitutions in the 81-bp region infers that a GC-biased gene conversion (BGC) might create these seemingly excessive substitutions. To evaluate the 81-bp function, we performed transgenic mouse assay of the HACNS1 construct lacking the 81-bp region. The deleted construct showed similar enhancer activity to the intact human HACNS1, suggesting that the function of the human 81-bp region is not an activating enhancer but rather a disrupted repressor. This result infers that loss of function in the HACNS1 81-bp region, possibly via a BGC, played an important role in human-specific evolution.