Effect of oral phytoestrogen on androgenicity and insulin sensitivity in postmenopausal women

The aim of this study was to determine and compare the effect of treatment with transdermal oestrogen and phytoestrogen on insulin sensitivity and sex hormone-binding globulin (SHBG) levels in healthy postmenopausal women.

Forty-three healthy postmenopausal women aged 68 ± 7 (mean ± SD) years who were not receiving hormonal replacement therapy completed a 3 month randomized drug therapy study. The participants were randomized to one of four groups: 0.05 mg or 0.1 mg transdermal oestrogen/day, or 40 or 80 mg oral phytoestrogen (Promensil)/day insulin sensitivity was indirectly measured using the quantitative insulin sensitivity check index (QUICKI). SHBG, total testosterone, oestradiol, and fasting glucose and insulin levels for calculation of insulin sensitivity were obtained at baseline and at monthly intervals during the 3 months of therapy.

In healthy nondiabetic postmenopausal women, the rate of change in QUICKI was significantly different between the red clover based phytoestrogen and transdermal oestrogen groups, so that after three months of therapy, QUICKI with red clover based phytoestrogen therapy was lower than that in the transdermal oestrogen group, p = 0.01. Red clover based phytoestrogen therapy was not associated with any changes in SHBG levels whereas transdermal estrogen therapy significantly increased SHBG levels, p = 0.05.

In contrast to transdermal oestrogen therapy, oral phytoestrogen therapy does not decrease androgenicity and is associated with a decrease in insulin sensitivity. These effects are similar to those of raloxifene and consistent with phytoestrogen's selective oestrogen receptor modulator properties.