Related Experiment Video
Updated: May 26, 2026
08:05
Microtensiometer for Confocal Microscopy Visualization of Dynamic Interfaces
Published on: September 9, 2022
Mechanical surface tension governs membrane thermal fluctuations
1Department of Biomedical Engineering, The Faculty of Engineering Sciences, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Be'er Sheva 84105, Israel.
Physical Review. E, Statistical, Nonlinear, and Soft Matter Physics
|December 21, 2011
Summary
Membrane fluctuation spectra are governed by mechanical tension, not intrinsic tension. Commonly used approximations of the Helfrich Hamiltonian yield incorrect mechanical tension calculations, contradicting prior theories.
Area of Science:
- Biophysics
- Soft Matter Physics
- Computational Physics
Background:
- The Helfrich effective Hamiltonian is a cornerstone for describing the mechanical properties of fluid membranes.
- Understanding membrane fluctuations is crucial for various biological processes and material science applications.
- Existing theoretical models often rely on approximations that may introduce inaccuracies.
Purpose of the Study:
- To investigate the governing tension in membrane spectra of thermal fluctuations.
- To analyze the validity and implications of the quadratic approximation in the Helfrich Hamiltonian.
- To resolve discrepancies between theoretical predictions and the physical behavior of membranes.
Main Methods:
- Analytical calculations to derive theoretical relationships.
- Computer simulations to model membrane behavior and thermal fluctuations.
- Comparison of results from approximated and exact theoretical frameworks.
Main Results:
- The membrane spectrum of thermal fluctuations is predominantly influenced by mechanical tension.
- The commonly used quadratic approximation of the Helfrich Hamiltonian lacks rotational invariance, a nonphysical characteristic.
- This approximation leads to a significant overestimation of mechanical tension compared to the true value.
Conclusions:
- Mechanical tension, not intrinsic tension, dictates the membrane spectrum of thermal fluctuations.
- The rotational non-invariance of the approximated Helfrich Hamiltonian necessitates a re-evaluation of its application.
- The simultaneous vanishing of mechanical and intrinsic tensions, as predicted by our findings, challenges existing theoretical models based on the approximated Hamiltonian.
Related Concept Videos
01:24Surface Tension
Surface tension is defined as the force per unit length (γ) acting along the surface of a liquid. It arises due to strong intermolecular forces of attraction. A molecule located inside the bulk of the liquid is surrounded by other molecules and experiences equal forces in all directions. However, a molecule at the surface experiences unbalanced forces because there are more neighboring molecules below than above. This creates a net inward force that pulls surface molecules toward the interior,...
01:22Surface Tension of Fluid
Surface tension is a fundamental property of fluids, occurring at the boundary between a liquid and a gas or between two immiscible liquids. This phenomenon arises from the cohesive forces between molecules at the fluid's surface, creating an effect similar to a stretched elastic membrane. Inside each fluid, molecules are equally attracted in all directions by neighboring molecules, but surface molecules experience a net inward force, resulting in surface tension.
Surface tension varies with...
Surface tension varies with...
01:16Surface Tension and Surface Energy
When a paint brush is immersed in water, the bristles wave freely inside the water. When it is taken out, the bristles stick together. The reason behind this effect is surface tension.
Consider a beaker filled with liquid. The bulk molecules in the liquid experience equal attractive forces on all sides with the surrounding molecules. However, the surface molecules experience a net attractive force downward due to the bulk molecules. The surface of the liquid behaves like a stretched membrane,...
Consider a beaker filled with liquid. The bulk molecules in the liquid experience equal attractive forces on all sides with the surrounding molecules. However, the surface molecules experience a net attractive force downward due to the bulk molecules. The surface of the liquid behaves like a stretched membrane,...
02:57Surface Tension, Capillary Action, and Viscosity
Surface Tension
The various IMFs between identical molecules of a substance are examples of cohesive forces. The molecules within a liquid are surrounded by other molecules and are attracted equally in all directions by the cohesive forces within the liquid. However, the molecules on the surface of a liquid are attracted only by about one-half as many molecules. Because of the unbalanced molecular attractions on the surface molecules, liquids contract to form a shape that minimizes the number...
The various IMFs between identical molecules of a substance are examples of cohesive forces. The molecules within a liquid are surrounded by other molecules and are attracted equally in all directions by the cohesive forces within the liquid. However, the molecules on the surface of a liquid are attracted only by about one-half as many molecules. Because of the unbalanced molecular attractions on the surface molecules, liquids contract to form a shape that minimizes the number...
01:23Membrane Fluidity
Cell membranes are composed of phospholipids, proteins, and carbohydrates loosely attached to one another through chemical interactions. Molecules are generally able to move about in the plane of the membrane, giving the membrane its flexible nature called fluidity. Two other features of the membrane contribute to membrane fluidity: the chemical structure of the phospholipids and the presence of cholesterol in the membrane.
01:26Membrane Fluidity
Membrane fluidity is explained by the fluid mosaic model of the cell membrane, which describes the plasma membrane structure as a mosaic of components—including phospholipids, cholesterol, proteins, and carbohydrates—that gives the membrane a fluid character.
Mosaic nature of the membrane
The mosaic characteristic of the membrane helps the plasma membrane remain fluid. The integral proteins and lipids exist as separate but loosely-attached molecules in the membrane. The membrane is a relatively...
Mosaic nature of the membrane
The mosaic characteristic of the membrane helps the plasma membrane remain fluid. The integral proteins and lipids exist as separate but loosely-attached molecules in the membrane. The membrane is a relatively...