Evaluation in vitro of several pyrrolizidine alkaloid carcinogens: observations on the essential pyrrolic nucleus

Six compounds related to pyrrolizidine alkaloids have been subjected to an in vitro mammalian cell transformation test. Two hepatocarcinogenic alkaloids (retrorsine and monocrotaline) and one synthetic analogue (synthanecine A bis-N-ethylcarbamate) gave positive results while a non-toxic alkaloid (rosmarinine) was negative in the test. Positive results were also given by dehydroretronecine, a secondary pyrrolic alkaloid metabolite, and the closely related synthetic compound 2,3-bishydroxymethyl-1-methylpyrrole. These observations lend support to the hypothesis that a simple alkylating pyrrole is the biologically active chemical agent derived from these alkaloids. The negative transformation response observed for the non-carcinogenic alkaloid rosmarinine establishes that the carcinogenic alkaloids are inducing transformation rather than simply selecting for spontaneous transformants. The mammalian-derived cells used in this study, unlike S. typhimurium, were capable of activating retrorsine in the absence of an auxiliary source of metabolising enzymes (S-9 mix).