Evidence-based therapy according to the guideline for gastric ulcers is cost-effective in Japan

Helicobacter pylori (H. pylori) infection is a major cause of gastric ulcers (GU) and eradication of the infection controls the ulcer with no requirement for maintenance therapy. In Japan, an evidence-based guideline (GL) was first published in 2003 (1(st) version) and then again in 2007 (2(nd) version) with a minor revision under support of the Japanese Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare (GUGLJ). Adherence to its standards is high, estimated at 80%. GU patients aged 18 or older with active ulcers at the time of diagnosis by an endoscopic examination at National Hospital Organization (NHO) hospitals of Japan were enrolled between September 2004 and April 2005. Subjective and endoscopic outcome, medical treatments and medical costs during the following nine months were analyzed, retrospectively. As a result, 935 patients and 270 doctors in charge from 62 NHO hospitals were analyzed. Among H. pylori-positive GU patients, the endoscopic recurrence rate of 24 patients with failure of eradication was 29.2%, which was significantly higher than 8.8% of 194 patients with successful eradication. Successful eradication of H. pylori resulted in significantly lower endoscopic recurrence rates for GU patients either with or without administration of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAID). GUGLJ adherence scores were significantly related to the specialty or knowledge on the GUGLJ of doctors in charge, and the total medical cost consumed. These results suggest that the therapy of GU along with an evidence-based GL is essential to implement cost-effective treatment and the GI experts or the doctors that understand the GUGLJ very well should perform it.