Surgical management of primary appendiceal malignancy

Primary appendiceal neoplasms are rare, with carcinoid being more common than carcinoma. Preoperative diagnosis is infrequent. We report a series of 24 primary appendiceal neoplasms treated over a 5-year period.

All primary appendiceal neoplasms diagnosed in a university teaching hospital between April 2003 and June 2008 were identified from the prospective histopathology database. Patient records were reviewed for clinical, operative and pathological data.

Fourteen carcinomas and 10 carcinoids were identified in the 5-year period. The former presented at median age 55.8 years with median symptom duration of 35 days, compared with 48 years and 3 days, respectively, for carcinoids. An abdominal mass was commoner in carcinomas (8/14 vs 1/10). Six patients with carcinoma underwent appendicectomy followed by completion right-hemicolectomy, two of whom had residual disease; seven underwent primary right-hemicolectomy and one had abscess drainage. Five patients with appendiceal carcinoma died of the disease during a median follow-up of 633 (256-1158) days. Six patients underwent appendicectomy for acute appendicitis, one had a primary right-hemicolectomy for a caecal mass. Three had a subsequent right-hemicolectomy for a high-risk carcinoid. An appendiceal carcinoid was an incidental finding in three right-hemicolectomy specimens removed for other indications. No metastases or deaths were recorded at median follow-up 451 (51-975) days.

Appendiceal carcinomas follow a more protracted clinical course than carcinoids, which usually present as acute appendicitis. Caution is needed when diagnosing simple appendicitis in older patients with longer symptom duration, particularly if a mass is present. Patients with appendiceal carcinoma should be offered completion right-hemicolectomy. Carcinoma has a poor prognosis.