Abbreviated MRI for patients presenting to the emergency department with hip pain

The objective of our study was to assess the diagnostic performance of two abbreviated hip MRI protocols--coronal STIR images only and coronal STIR with coronal T1-weighted images--as compared with a full hip MRI protocol in patients presenting to the emergency department (ED) with hip pain and negative radiographic findings.

The cohort included 385 patients (277 females, 108 males; mean age, 61 years; age range, 16-99 years) who underwent MRI within 1 month of negative radiographs obtained for ED evaluation of hip pain between January 2000 and March 2009. MR examinations were graded independently by two musculoskeletal fellowship-trained emergency radiologists for detection of fracture, avascular necrosis (AVN), and muscle injury in three subsets: coronal STIR images only; coronal STIR images and coronal T1-weighted images; and the full examination.

MRI detected findings suspicious for fracture in 42% (162/385) of patients, for AVN in 9% (33/385), and for muscle injury in 35% (134/385). The sensitivity and specificity of STIR alone in raising concern for fracture was 99% (220/223) for both readers, with small incremental benefits of adding coronal T1-weighted images. For AVN, specificity was 100% (28/28) with STIR alone, but the addition of coronal T1-weighted images provided substantial benefit by increasing sensitivity from 85% (28/33) to 97% (32/33). For muscle injury, sensitivity and specificity exceeded 95% (128/134) for both abbreviated examinations.

An abbreviated MRI protocol including coronal STIR and coronal T1-weighted images has high sensitivity and specificity for fracture, AVN, and muscle injury in ED patients presenting with hip pain and negative radiographs.