Accuracy evaluation of surgical guides in implant dentistry by non-contact reverse engineering techniques

In the paper laser scanning was used to evaluate, by indirect methods, the accuracy of computer-designed surgical guides in the oral implant supported rehabilitation of partially or completely edentulous patients.

Five implant supported rehabilitations for a total of twenty-three implants were carried out by computer-designed surgical guides, performed with the master model developed by muco-compressive and muco-static impressions. For all cases the surgical virtual planning, starting from 3D models obtained by dental scan DICOM data, was performed. The implants were inserted on the pre-surgical casts in the position defined in the virtual planning. These positions were acquired by three-dimensional optical laser scanning and compared with the laser scans of the intraoral impressions taken post-operatively.

The comparison between the post-surgical implant replica positions and the positions in the pre-operative cast, for the five patients, shows a maximum distance in the range 1.02-1.25 mm, an average distance in the range 0.21-0.41 mm and a standard deviation in the range 0.21-0.29 mm.

The results of this research demonstrate accurate transfer of implant replica position by virtual implant insertion into a pre-operative cast and a post-operative cast obtained from impressioning. In previous studies the evaluation of the implant positions have required a post-surgical CT scan. With the indirect methods by laser scanning technique, proposed in the paper, this extra radiation exposure of the patient can be eliminated.