Elders' preferences for life-prolonging treatment and their proxies' substituted judgment: influence of the elders' current health
Related Experiment Video
Updated: May 19, 2026

Oral Health Assessment by Lay Personnel for Older Adults
Published on: February 2, 2020
Laraine Winter1, Susan M Parks
1Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia VA Medical Center, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA. laraine.winter@gmail.com
Objective:
People in poor health tend to view life-prolonging treatments (e.g., tube feeding) as more acceptable than do healthier people. Do proxies' substituted judgments reveal a similar tendency, showing greater acceptance when the elder is in worse health?
Method:
In a cross-sectional telephone-based survey of 202 elderly individuals and their proxies, preferences for 4 life-prolonging treatments in 7 health prospects were examined in relation to the elder's current health status, operationalized as number of deficits in activities of daily living.
Results:
Stronger preferences for life-prolonging treatments in worse-health prospects were expressed by both elders and proxies when the elders' current health was relatively poor. The interaction effect was at least as pronounced for proxies' substituted judgment as for elders' own preferences.
Discussion:
Findings provide important insight into proxy decision making and have particular implications for proxy decision making on behalf of elders with dementia or other causes of decisional incapacity.
Related Concept Videos
Ethical Issues
Ethical Concerns in Healthcare:
Drug Dosing: Geriatric Patients
Standards of Care II
Ethical Dilemmas II
Pharmacokinetics in Geriatric Patients: Effect of Age on Drug Excretion
Pharmacodynamics in Geriatric Patients: Effects of Age