Selective use of hand and forearm muscles during bone screw insertion: a natural torque meter

To compare the maximum torque produced by different muscle groups and its influence on mini-implant insertion torque and fracture prevention.

Eighty-seven professionals were evaluated for the maximum torque produced on a screwdriver by a combined action between the thumb and index finger (maximum digital torque [MDT]) and by the forearm supination movement (maximum brachial torque [MBT]). Ninety mini-implants distributed among 9 different diameters were fractured to determine the fracture torque (FT). The fracture resistance index (FRI) was obtained from: FRI_MDT = FT/MDT and FRI_MBT = FT/MBT. Analysis of variance and t tests were used to compare the groups.

The MDT was smaller than the MBT, and the 2 measurements were smaller in female subjects. The FT increased for each 0.1-mm increment in diameter. The FRI_MDT was greater than FRI_MBT for all diameters. An FRI_MDT greater than 1 was found when the diameter was greater than or equal to 1.5 mm. An FRI_MBT greater than 1 occurred with diameters equal to or greater than 1.7 mm for female subjects and 1.8 mm for male subjects.

The digital torque was 42% smaller than the brachial torque, and it was mechanically safer and biologically more compatible, allowing the prevention of the fracture of mini-implants with a diameter 1.5 mm or thicker owing to an insertion torque limitation at 15 N-cm.