Related Experiment Video
Updated: May 17, 2026
06:04
Simulation of the Planetary Interior Differentiation Processes in the Laboratory
Published on: November 15, 2013
Forming a Moon with an Earth-like composition via a giant impact
1Planetary Science Directorate, Southwest Research Institute, 1050 Walnut Street, Suite 300, Boulder, CO 80302, USA. robin@boulder.swri.edu
Science (New York, N.Y.)
|October 19, 2012
Summary
Giant impact theory simulations show larger impactors can explain Earth and Moon's identical oxygen isotopes. This resolves a key challenge for the Moon's formation via planetary collision.
Area of Science:
- Planetary Science
- Geochemistry
- Lunar Science
Background:
- The giant impact theory posits the Moon formed from debris after a planetary collision with early Earth.
- A significant challenge to this theory is the nearly identical oxygen isotope composition of Earth and the Moon.
- Previous models suggested impactor material would dominate the debris disk, contradicting observed isotopic similarities.
Purpose of the Study:
- To investigate if larger impactors in giant impact simulations can reconcile Earth and Moon's isotopic compositions.
- To address the discrepancy between impactor-dominated disk predictions and observed Earth-Moon oxygen isotope similarity.
Main Methods:
- Conducted impact simulations using larger impactor sizes than previously explored.
- Analyzed the composition of the resulting debris disk in relation to the planet's mantle.
Main Results:
- Simulations with larger impactors successfully produced a debris disk with a composition matching the planet's mantle.
- This outcome aligns with the observed isotopic similarities between Earth and the Moon.
- The model necessitates subsequent angular momentum removal via solar resonance.
Conclusions:
- Larger impactors provide a viable mechanism for forming a Moon-consistent with Earth's isotopic signature.
- This resolves a major challenge for the giant impact theory.
- The proposed mechanism requires additional processes like solar resonance for angular momentum transfer.
More Related Videos
09:44Laboratory Drop Towers for the Experimental Simulation of Dust-aggregate Collisions in the Early Solar System
Published on: June 5, 2014
11:50Metal-silicate Partitioning at High Pressure and Temperature: Experimental Methods and a Protocol to Suppress Highly Siderophile Element Inclusions
Published on: June 13, 2015
Related Concept Videos
01:27Gravity between Spherical Bodies
Newton's law of gravitation describes the gravitational force between any two point masses. However, for extended spherical objects like the Earth, the Moon, and other planets, the law holds with an assumption that masses of spherical objects are concentrated at their respective centers.
This assumption can be proved easily by showing that the expression for gravitational potential energy between a hollow sphere of mass (M) and a point mass (m) is the same as it would be for a pair of extended...
This assumption can be proved easily by showing that the expression for gravitational potential energy between a hollow sphere of mass (M) and a point mass (m) is the same as it would be for a pair of extended...
01:16Gravitation
In the years before Newton, a general belief prevailed that different laws governed objects in the sky than objects on Earth. When Kepler wrote down the three laws of planetary motion, explaining in detail the geometrical properties of the planetary orbits around the Sun, there was no immediate idea to discern their connection with more fundamental laws. It was Isaac Newton who, in 1665–66, figured out the connection between planetary motion, the motion of the moon around the Earth, and the...
02:06Conditions on Early Earth
Around 4 billion years ago, oceans began to condense on earth while volcanic eruptions released nitrogen, carbon dioxide, methane, ammonia, and hydrogen into the primordial atmosphere. However, organisms with the characteristics of life were not initially present on earth. Scientists have used experimentation to determine how organisms evolved that could grow, reproduce, and maintain an internal environment.
02:06Conditions on Early Earth
Around 4 billion years ago, oceans began to condense on earth while volcanic eruptions released nitrogen, carbon dioxide, methane, ammonia, and hydrogen into the primordial atmosphere. However, organisms with the characteristics of life were not initially present on earth. Scientists have used experimentation to determine how organisms evolved that could grow, reproduce, and maintain an internal environment.
01:06Tidal Forces
The origin of Earth's ocean tides has been a subject of continuous investigation for over 2000 years. However, the work of Newton is considered to be the beginning of the proper understanding of the phenomenon. Ocean tides are the result of gravitational tidal forces. These same tidal forces are present in any astronomical body; they are responsible for the internal heat that creates the volcanic activity on Io, one of Jupiter's moons, and the breakup of stars that get too close to black holes.
01:42Simple Harmonic Motion and Uniform Circular Motion
While simple harmonic motion and uniform circular motion may be two separate concepts, they correlate and interlink with each other. Simple harmonic motion is an oscillatory motion in a system where the net force can be described by Hooke's law, while uniform circular motion is the motion of an object in a circular path at constant speed.
There is an easy way to produce simple harmonic motion by using uniform circular motion. For instance, consider a ball attached to a uniformly rotating...
There is an easy way to produce simple harmonic motion by using uniform circular motion. For instance, consider a ball attached to a uniformly rotating...