Related Experiment Video
Updated: May 15, 2026
12:31
In Vivo Modeling of the Morbid Human Genome using Danio rerio
Published on: August 24, 2013
Candidate gene studies of a promising intermediate phenotype: failure to replicate
Amy B Hart1, Harriet de Wit, Abraham A Palmer
1Department of Human Genetics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637, USA.
Summary
Replicating candidate gene studies on amphetamine response failed. This suggests issues with study design, sample size, and publication bias in genetic research.
Area of Science:
- Pharmacogenomics
- Neuroscience
- Human Genetics
Background:
- Candidate gene studies often use intermediate phenotypes, like drug responses, assuming simpler genetic architectures.
- Pharmacogenomic drug challenge studies are proposed as a promising intermediate phenotype for genetic association studies.
- Previous research identified candidate genes associated with amphetamine response in healthy volunteers.
Purpose of the Study:
- To replicate previously identified genetic associations for acute subjective and physiological responses to amphetamine.
- To investigate the reliability and reproducibility of candidate gene findings in pharmacogenomic studies.
- To assess factors contributing to non-replication in genetic association studies.
Main Methods:
- Replication study using identical methodology with over 200 additional healthy human volunteers.
- Analysis of candidate genes (e.g., ADORA2A, SLC6A3, BDNF) previously associated with amphetamine response.
- Comparison of results from the initial study and the replication cohort.
Main Results:
- None of the previously identified candidate gene associations for amphetamine response were replicated.
- The replication attempt failed to confirm the initial findings in a larger, independent sample.
- Effect sizes in candidate gene studies may be smaller than anticipated or highly variable.
Conclusions:
- Non-replication of candidate gene findings is a significant issue in genetic research.
- Factors such as statistical power, sample size, multiple testing, and publication bias may contribute to failed replications.
- Caution is advised for similarly designed candidate gene studies due to potential reproducibility challenges.
Related Concept Videos
01:43Incomplete Dominance
Gregor Mendel's work (1822 - 1884) was primarily focused on pea plants. Through his initial experiments, he determined that every gene in a diploid cell has two variants called alleles inherited from each parent. He suggested that amongst these two alleles, one allele is dominant in character and the other recessive. The combination of alleles determines the phenotype of a gene in an organism.
01:09Epistasis Analysis
Although Mendel chose seven unrelated traits in peas to study gene segregation, most traits involve multiple gene interactions that create a spectrum of phenotypes. When the interaction of various genes or alleles at different locations influences a phenotype, this is called epistasis. Epistasis often involves one gene masking or interfering with the expression of another (antagonistic epistasis). Epistasis often occurs when different genes are part of the same biochemical pathway. The...
02:41Lethal Alleles
Agouti: A Lethal Allele
Lucien Cuénot discovered lethal alleles in 1905 while studying the inheritance of coat color in mice. The agouti gene is responsible for the color of the coat in mice. This gene codes for an agouti-signaling protein, which is responsible for melanin distribution in mammals. The wild-type allele gives rise to gray-brown coat color in mice, while the mutant allele gives rise to yellow coat color. In addition to coat color, the agouti gene is associated with the yellow...
Lucien Cuénot discovered lethal alleles in 1905 while studying the inheritance of coat color in mice. The agouti gene is responsible for the color of the coat in mice. This gene codes for an agouti-signaling protein, which is responsible for melanin distribution in mammals. The wild-type allele gives rise to gray-brown coat color in mice, while the mutant allele gives rise to yellow coat color. In addition to coat color, the agouti gene is associated with the yellow...
02:30Genomic Imprinting and Inheritance
Diploid organisms inherit genetic material through chromosomes from both parents. Copies of the same gene are known as alleles. In most cases, both alleles are simultaneously expressed and allow various cellular processes to function optimally. If one of the alleles is missing or mutated, the expression of the other allele can compensate; however, this is not true for all genes.
The expression of some genes depends on which parent passed the gene to the offspring, through a phenomenon known as...
The expression of some genes depends on which parent passed the gene to the offspring, through a phenomenon known as...
02:46Genetic Screens
Genetic screens are tools used to identify genes and mutations responsible for phenotypes of interest. Genetic screens help identify individuals or a group of people at risk of developing genetic diseases and help them with early intervention, targeted therapy, and reproductive options.
Forward genetic screens
Forward or “classical” genetic screens involve creating random mutations in an organism’s DNA using radiation, mutagens, or insertion of additional bases, which result in visible changes...
Forward genetic screens
Forward or “classical” genetic screens involve creating random mutations in an organism’s DNA using radiation, mutagens, or insertion of additional bases, which result in visible changes...
02:27Background and Environment Affect Phenotype
Although the genetic makeup of an organism plays a major role in determining the phenotype, there are also several environmental factors, such as temperature, oxygen availability, presence of mutagens, that can alter an organism’s phenotype.
An example of how genetic background affects phenotype can be seen in horses. The Extension gene in horses is responsible for their coat color. A wild-type gene (EE) produces black pigment in the coat, while a mutant gene (ee) produces red pigment. A...
An example of how genetic background affects phenotype can be seen in horses. The Extension gene in horses is responsible for their coat color. A wild-type gene (EE) produces black pigment in the coat, while a mutant gene (ee) produces red pigment. A...