Related Experiment Video
Updated: May 14, 2026

Evaluating the Effects of Different Polishing Methods on Color Stability of Dental Restorations in Pediatric Dentistry
Published on: June 6, 2025
Developing a custom dental porcelain shade system for computer color matching.
Shigemi Ishikawa-Nagai1, Jian Wang, Alison Seliger
1Department of Restorative Dentistry and Biomaterials Sciences, Harvard School of Dental Medicine, Boston, MA, United States.
This study aimed to improve dental shade matching by creating a new porcelain shade system. Researchers mapped natural tooth colors and compared them with existing guides like Vitapan and 3D Master. They developed 21 new shades, including modifiers like pink and grey, and tested them on zirconia substrates. The new system covers a broader range than natural teeth and existing guides. It aligns well with 3D Master and is suitable for computer color matching. The system's design allows for better shade selection in clinical settings. The study suggests the system could be a useful improvement over current methods.
Area of Science:
- Dental materials science within restorative dentistry
- Colorimetry in clinical dentistry
- Computer-aided shade matching
Background:
Natural tooth color variation is complex and spans multiple dimensions. Traditional shade guides like Vitapan Classic and 3D Master have limitations in capturing full color diversity. Existing systems often fail to cover the full spectrum of tooth color. Prior research has shown that current shade systems may leave gaps in color representation. This gap motivated the need for a more comprehensive system. No prior work had resolved how to expand shade coverage effectively. The study aimed to address this limitation through a new design approach. The goal was to create a system that better aligns with natural tooth color distributions.
Purpose Of The Study:
The study aimed to develop a new dental porcelain shade system that expands the color range beyond existing systems. It sought to create a system that matches natural tooth color more accurately. The motivation came from limitations in current shade guides. The team wanted to incorporate computer color matching techniques. They focused on generating a system with broader coverage. The study also aimed to ensure compatibility with zirconia substrates. The goal was to improve shade selection in clinical settings. The new system needed to be tested for practical application.
Main Methods:
The researchers first mapped 176 maxillary natural incisors to define tooth color distribution. They compared this with two existing shade guides: Vitapan Classic and 3D Master. Next, they plotted 15 shades and six modifiers on the color map. The team selected 12 shades around the perimeter and nine within clusters. They used trial and error based on prior formulations to create new shades. The porcelain powders were layered on zirconia substrates at 1.0mm thickness. Ceramic disks were fabricated to test the new shades. The color distribution was analyzed using L*-C* and a*-b* maps.
Main Results:
The new system included 21 shades, covering a broader range than natural teeth and existing guides. The L*-C* and a*-b* maps showed the new system extended beyond the natural color space. The 21-shade system had better coverage than the 3D Master system. The system included shades like NW-0, A1, A2, and modifiers like pink and grey. The new system demonstrated homogeneity with 3D Master. The color distribution was larger than the natural tooth range. The zirconia substrate supported the layered porcelain effectively. The results suggest the system is suitable for computer color matching.
Conclusions:
The authors concluded that the new 21-shade system expands the color range beyond existing systems. It aligns with natural tooth color distributions and includes modifiers for better accuracy. The system is compatible with zirconia substrates at 1.0mm thickness. The findings suggest it can be used in computer color matching systems. The system's homogeneity with 3D Master supports its practical use. The broader coverage may improve shade selection in clinical settings. The study did not claim the system is essential but proposed it as an improvement. The authors emphasized the system's potential for integration into existing workflows.
Frequently Asked Questions
The new system includes 21 shades covering a broader range than natural teeth and existing guides.
The new system has a larger color distribution and better homogeneity with 3D Master.
The 1.0mm thickness was selected to ensure compatibility with zirconia substrates.
Modifiers like pink and grey help achieve more accurate shade representation.
Formulations were determined through trial and error informed by prior research.
The system can be incorporated into computer color matching systems for improved shade selection.
