Molecular mechanics and dynamics of an abasic frameshift in DNA and comparison to NMR data

In a previous publication (Ph. Cuniasse, L.C. Sowers, R. Eritja, B. Kaplan, M.F. Goodman, J.A.H. Cognet, M. Le Bret, W. Guschlbauer and G.V. Fazakerley, Biochemistry 28, 2018 (1989), we determined by two dimensional NMR studies and molecular mechanics calculations the three-dimensional structure of a non-selfcomplementary oligonucleotide: [sequence; see text] where dr, at the center of the first strand, is a model abasic site. In order to explain all the results arising from NMR measurements, we found that an equilibrium between two conformations was necessary. These conformations differ mainly by the sugar pucker of G5 which is C2' endo or C3' endo. The latter is stabilized by addition of counterions between phosphate residues P3 and P4. In this paper, we have constructed systematically, all possible structures as a function of torsion angles delta of dr4 and of G5 by molecular mechanics in the presence or absence of counterions. Since these conformations were not forced with NMR distance measurements, this method allows detailed comparisons between all possible conformations and NMR data. Maps of contour lines of the potential energy, of fits to NMR distance measurements, and of helical twist as a function of torsion angles delta of dr4 and of G5 unravel the difficulties associated with the study of the G5 sugar pucker conformation equilibrium. Sugar puckers and proton distances are very sensitive criteria to monitor molecular dynamics. Relying on these experimental criteria, we have tested many molecular dynamics preparation phases and we propose a new warm-up and equilibration procedure for molecular dynamics. Thus we show with a 290 ps molecular dynamic run that G5 is in conformational equilibrium and that all NMR data are well reproduced.