Making ERCP training safe: A protocol-based strategy to minimize complications during selective biliary cannulation

Endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) is an advanced procedure with significant complication rate of 5 to 10%. Scant data is available on quality indicators for trainee-involved ERCP. In our study, we evaluated the outcome of trainee-involved ERCPs in which a protocol-based strategy to minimize complications during selective biliary cannulation was adopted.

Hands-on training was excluded if patients had ASA grade > 3. The trainee's attempts at selective biliary cannulation were stopped and the procedure taken over by the supervising expert endoscopist if the following factors were encountered: (1) failed cannulation after 5 attempts; (2) unsuccessful cannulation after 10 minutes; (3) edematous papilla; (4) pancreatic duct cannulation ≥ 2 times. After successful ductal cannulation, the trainee was allowed to continue additional hands on training in other aspects such as stone extraction and stenting.

During the study period, 331 patients underwent ERCP. Trainee group (TG) consisted of 85 patients; mean age 70 (range 27-99). Expert group (EG) consisted of 246 patients; mean age 65 (range 19-98). The overall technical success rate was 97.9% and there was no significant difference between TG (98.8%) and EG (97.6%). The overall complication rate was 3.9% and there was no difference between TG (3.5%) and EG (4%). In TG, although inadvertent pancreatic duct cannulation occurred in 12/85 (14.1%), acute pancreatitis developed only in 3/85 (3.5%).

The high success and low complication rates in trainee-involved and expert-only ERCP procedures were similar. While using a protocol-based strategy, good clinical outcome during the provision of hands-on training for ERCP was observed.