Re-evaluation of myoclonin1 immunosignals in neuron, mitotic spindle, and midbody--nonspecific?

Mutations in EFHC1 gene cause juvenile myoclonic epilepsy (JME). We previously showed that myoclonin1 protein encoded by EFHC1 is expressed in prenatal choroid plexus and postnatal ependymal cell cilia but may not be in neurons. However, another group reported that myoclonin1 is expressed in neurons and at mitotic spindle, and that the suppression of EFHC1 by RNAi caused disruption of mitotic spindle structure, impaired M-phase progression, and an increase of apoptosis. We re-investigated their results by using the same polyclonal antibody that they used, and found that the signals in neurons remained in Efhc1-deficient mouse, suggesting that the signals in neurons were nonspecific. Furthermore, Efhc1 (-/-) mouse did not show any abnormalities such as disruption of mitotic spindle structure, impaired M-phase progression, and an increase of apoptosis. Further investigations are required to clarify these discrepancies.