Variable expression of the herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase gene in Nicotiana tabacum affects negative selection

The potentials and limitations of negative-selection systems based on the human herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase type-1 (HSVtk) gene, which causes sensitivity to the nucleoside analog ganciclovir, were examined in tobacco as a model system. There were great differences between individual HSVtk(+) transgenic plants in ganciclovir sensitivity. Inhibition of growth while under selection correlated with HSVtk-tianscnpt levels. Negative selection against HSVtk(+) transformants at the level of Agrobacterium-mediated transformation using a ganciclo-vir/kanamycin double-selection medium (the positive selection marker neomycin phosphotransferase-II gene was in the transformation vector) resulted in a three- to six-fold reduction in the frequency of kanamycin-resistant shoots. The efficiency of negative selection in this case was limited due to the great variation in HSVtk expression, i.e., the frequently occurring transformants with low, or no, ganciclovir sensitivity escaping negative selection. Two independently constructed HSVtk genes showed the same variability of the phenotype in Nicotiana tabacum transformants. Distinct phenotypes, ranging from no regeneration through abnormal or delayed regeneration, were observed when leaf segments were placed on shoot-inducing medium supplemented with 10(-6)-10(-3) M ganciclovir. The highest HSVtk mRNA and ganciclovir sensitivity levels were observed in plants which were transformed with the pSLJ882 chimeric construct. The pSLJ882 plant expression vector carried the coding sequence of HSVtk, whereas plasmid pCX305.1 carried an HSVtk construct retaining the untranslated 5 leader and viral 3 regions. The pCX305.1 transformants showed, at most, a delayed formation of shoots with thin stems and very narrow leaves. Ganciclovir sensitivity showed typical Mendelian segregation. A gene-dosage effect was also seen at the seedling level in the progeny of two transgenic lines.