Stress ethylene: A bioassay for rhizosphere-applied phytotoxicants

A bioassay for rhizosphere-applied phytotoxicants was developed and evaluated with a broad range of chemicals. Test substances were applied to the rhizosphere of whole, intact bush bean plants (Phaseolus vulgaris L. cv. Bush Blue Lake 290) grown in a solid support medium and the resultant ethylene production was measured to detect the presence of phytotoxic materials. The beans were encapsulated in plastic bags for 2 hr following treatment and then incubated for 24 hr in the dark. Ethylene and ethane accumulating within the bags were quantified via gas-solid chromatography. The application of various concentrations of inorganic and organic chemicals induced various responses. No single equation adequately described the dose-response curves; therefore, a critical value (a statistically significant increase in stress ethylene) was computed for each test substance. A phytotoxic-response threshold for each test substance was defined as the test-substance concentration that caused ethylene production to exceed its respective critical-value concentration. Based on threshold concentrations determined by analysis of stress ethylene production, the relative phytotoxicity rankings of the inorganic test substances were: CdCl2>CuCl2>Pb(C2H3O2)2>LiCl, while those of the organic test substances were 2,4-D esters>paraquat dichloride>1-butanol>2-propanone>2-propanol. Both stress ethylene and ethane production were nonresponsive to hydrogen-ion concentration (measured before application) over a broad pH range. However, significant ethane production was detected at pH 2 and stress ethylene was produced at pH 1. The measurement of stress-induced ethylene provides a rapid and simple means to determine the relative phytoxicity of rhizosphere-applied substances.