Short and medium-term therapeutic effects of pneumatic dilatation for achalasia: a 15-year tertiary centre experience

Pneumatic dilatation (PD) is a commonly used endoscopic technique to weaken the lower oesophageal sphincter in patients with achalasia. It is considered as the most effective non-surgical therapeutic option for achalasia, but further data on the overall effectiveness and rate of complications is needed.

To determine the short- and medium-term therapeutic effectiveness of PD for achalasia and estimate the cumulative probability of remaining in remission over one year after a single treatment. The study also aimed to identify clinical predictors of therapeutic outcome achieved by PD and assess for PD-related complications.

A total of 26 patients with achalasia who were treated with PD between 1997 and 2011 at a tertiary care centre were followed for up to 1 year. Data related to demographics, clinical symptoms and PD-related complications were collected. Short (1 and 3 months) and medium (1 year) term therapeutic effectiveness of PD was assessed with the use of the Eckhart scoring system for evaluation of clinical symptoms. The probability of staying in remission one year after a single PD was determined by using a Kaplan-Meier estimator. In order to prevent major complications, limited maximal pressure of no more than 11 PSI was used during PD.

Twenty-six patients with symptomatic achalasia (mean age 47.1±18.5 years, 82% males) underwent 44 PD procedures (mean 1.7/patient). Thirteen patients (50%) had a single PD, 10 patients (38%) had two dilatations, and 3 patients (12%) had three or more dilatations over one year. Nineteen out of the 26 patients (73%) were in remission at one and three months each, following the initial PD. Seventeen out of the 26 patients (65%) remained in remission after one year. A total of 5 patients (19%) were referred for surgery over 1 year due to lack of success of the endoscopic treatment. The mean Eckhart symptom scores, at 1 month (3.2±1.2), 3 months (3.5±1.3) and 1 year (1.8±0.6) after the initial PD, were significantly lower when compared to the mean initial Eckhart symptom score (9.7±4.4, P<0.05). Using a symptom score above 3 as a cutoff value for treatment failure, the probability of remaining in remission (relapse-free) after a single dilatation was 35% at one year. Patient gender appeared as an important treatment outcome predictor. Namely, 4 of the 5 patients (80%) with PD treatment failure were males. There were no major complications from the 44 PDs. One patient (3.8%) developed significant heartburn. The majority of PDs (33/44, 75%) were followed with minor, subclinical oesophageal mucosal bleeding from the dilation site as seen on post-dilation oesophagoscopy.

Pneumatic dilatation is an effective short and medium term treatment option for the majority of patients with achalasia without significant related complications. Further studies are warranted to assess the possible role of limited maximal pressure use of no more than 11 PSI during PD in preventing oesophageal perforations.