Evaluation of prostate-specific antigen and prostatic acid phosphatase as prostate cancer markers

Prostate-specific antigen (PSA) and prostatic acid phosphatase (PAP) have been evaluated in patients with prostate cancer, benign prostatic hypertrophy (BPH), and prostatitis. PSA has proved to be diagnostically more sensitive than PAP for the detection of prostate cancer: 95.0 per cent vs 60.0 per cent for 40 newly diagnosed cancer cases, and 97.1 per cent vs 65.7 per cent for 35 relapsed cases. This also holds true for those patients with early-stage disease: 71.4 per cent vs 0 per cent for 7 Stage A1 cases. The specificities of PSA and PAP are comparable, 96.8 per cent vs 98.9 per cent, respectively. PSA is also more sensitive for monitoring therapy, since it usually rises before PAP and always precedes clinical signs of relapse. Although PSA may be elevated more frequently than PAP in some patients with BPH and prostatitis, it is postulated that these patients with elevated serum PSA and normal serum PAP may fall into a high-risk sub-population which may have early prostate cancer or precancerous conditions not easily detectable by current clinical and diagnostic techniques. Our data suggest PSA is a sensitive useful tumor marker for the diagnosis and management of prostate cancer. In addition, PAP, in combination with PSA, may serve as a useful adjunct for differential diagnosis and confirmation of advanced stage prostate cancer.