[Magnesium: a supercation misunderstood? Overview and survey of GPs in "Ille-et-Vilaine"]

Marie Penquerc'h1, Denis Picot2, Cécile Vigneau3

  • 1Service de néphrologie, CHU de Rennes, 2, rue Le Guilloux, 35033 Rennes, France.

Nephrologie & Therapeutique
|December 28, 2013
PubMed

Insights

Most general practitioners (GPs) frequently prescribe magnesium supplements, often without a clear indication, due to widespread information and patient requests. This practice highlights a disconnect between clinical need and prescription habits for magnesium therapy.

Area of Science:

  • Pharmacology and Therapeutics
  • General Practice and Primary Care
  • Mineral Metabolism

Background:

  • Magnesium supplementation has numerous attributed medical indications, creating a complex therapeutic landscape despite limited evidence of widespread deficiency.
  • Real hypomagnesemia is rare, yet oral magnesium drugs are widely prescribed.
  • In France, the High Authority for Health (HAS) only approves magnesium supplementation for proven magnesium deficiency.

Purpose of the Study:

  • To review current knowledge regarding magnesium's therapeutic uses.
  • To analyze the prescribing practices of general practitioners (GPs) concerning magnesium supplementation.

Main Methods:

  • A cross-sectional study involving 100 general practitioners in Ille-et-Vilaine, France.
  • An e-questionnaire with 27 questions (38 items) was administered after telephone agreement.
  • Data collected included prescribing practices, knowledge of magnesium, and demographic information.

Main Results:

  • 96% of responding GPs frequently prescribe magnesium, with 70% finding it relevant to their practice.
  • A significant 26% of GPs prescribe magnesium even when they do not perceive a clear clinical indication.
  • Prescriptions initiated by specialists or patients (often influenced by media/internet) accounted for only 7% each.

Conclusions:

  • General practitioners' knowledge and prescribing habits for magnesium are heavily influenced by the pharmaceutical industry and patient demand.
  • There is a notable discrepancy between the prevalence of magnesium prescribing and the actual incidence of diagnosed hypomagnesemia.
  • Further education and evidence-based guidelines are needed to align magnesium prescribing practices with established medical indications.

Related Concept Videos

Magnetism01:30

Magnetism

Magnets are commonly found in everyday objects, such as toys, hangers, elevators, doorbells, and computer devices. Experimentation on these magnets shows that all magnets have two poles: one is labeled north (N) and the other south (S). Magnetic poles repel if they are alike and attract if unlike. Moreover, both poles of a magnet attract unmagnetized pieces of iron.
An individual magnetic pole cannot be isolated. No matter how small, every piece of a magnet contains a north pole and a south...
8.2K
Paramagnetism01:30

Paramagnetism

Paramagnets are materials with unpaired electrons that possess a finite magnetic moment. In the absence of a magnetic field, these moments are randomly oriented, and thus the net moment is zero. Under an external field, a torque acting on the moments tends to align them along the field's direction. However, the random thermal motion of electrons produces a torque opposite to the external field and tries to disorient the moments. These two competing effects align only a few moments along the...
2.4K
Magnetic Fields01:27

Magnetic Fields

A moving charge or a current creates a magnetic field in the surrounding space, in addition to its electric field. The magnetic field exerts a force on any other moving charge or current that is present in the field. Like an electric field, the magnetic field is also a vector field. At any position, the direction of the magnetic field is defined as the direction in which the north pole of a compass needle points.
A magnetic field is defined by the force that a charged particle experiences...
6.0K
Diamagnetism01:26

Diamagnetism

Materials consisting of paired electrons have zero net magnetic moments. However, when these materials are placed under an external magnetic field, the moments opposite to the field are induced. Such materials are called diamagnets. Diamagnetism is the response of the diamagnets when placed in an external magnetic field.
Diamagnetism was discovered by Anton Brugmans in 1778 when he observed that bismuth gets repelled by magnetic fields, thus theorizing that diamagnets get repelled by magnets....
2.8K
Ferromagnetism01:31

Ferromagnetism

Materials like iron, nickel, and cobalt consist of magnetic domains, within which the magnetic dipoles are arranged parallel to each other. The magnetic dipoles are rigidly aligned in the same direction within a domain by quantum mechanical coupling among the atoms. This coupling is so strong that even thermal agitation at room temperature cannot break it. The result is that each domain has a net dipole moment. However, some materials have weaker coupling, and are ferromagnetic at lower...
2.8K
Other Unique Bacteria01:18

Other Unique Bacteria

Magnetic bacteria exhibit a directed movement called magnetotaxis, driven by structures called magnetosomes. These magnetosomes consist of chains of magnetic particles made of either magnetite (Fe₃O₄) or greigite (Fe₃S₄) and are organized in a linear conformation by a protein scaffold within invaginations of the cell membrane. The bacteria align along the north–south magnetic field lines, much like a compass needle. They are typically microaerophilic or anaerobic...
576