Beta-adrenergic relaxation of smooth muscle: differences between cells and tissues

The present studies were carried out in an attempt to resolve the controversy about the Na+ dependence of beta-adrenergic relaxation in smooth muscle. Previous studies on isolated smooth muscle cells from the toad stomach had suggested that at least some of the actions of beta-adrenergic agents, including a stimulatory effect on 45Ca efflux, were dependent on the presence of a normal transmembrane Na+ gradient. Studies by other investigators using tissues derived from mammalian sources had suggested that the relaxing effect of beta-adrenergic agents was Na+ independent. Uncertainty remained as to whether these discrepancies reflected differences between cells and tissues or differences between species. Thus, in the present studies, we utilized both tissues and cells from the same source, the stomach muscle of the toad Bufo marinus, and assessed the Na+ dependence of beta-adrenergic relaxation. We found that elimination of a normal Na+ gradient abolished beta-adrenergic relaxation of isolated cells. In tissues, however, similar manipulations had no effect on relaxation. The reasons for this discrepancy are unclear but do not appear to be attributable to changes in smooth muscle function following enzymatic dispersion. Rather they may be attributable to unique properties of tissues, such as the presence of pacemaker cells, nerves, and so on. Thus the controversy concerning the mechanism of beta-adrenergic relaxation may reflect inherent differences between tissues and cells.