An evaluation of five tests to diagnose prostate cancer

In an effort to determine which of five tests was the most efficient in the diagnosis of prostate cancer, 280 male patients were screened employing aspiration cytology, transrectal ultrasound, acid phosphatase, prostate specific antigen, and the digital rectal examination. The digital rectal examination was the most efficient (75%) and in order of decreasing accuracy were prostate specific antigen (74%), prostatic ultrasound (71%), acid phosphatase (66%), and finally aspiration cytology (63%). In an era when what are more expensive and more technology are assumed to be better, what is simple and traditional is ignored. From an evaluation of these patients it appears that the digital rectal examination still retains its diagnostic efficiency. Finally, in this age of escalating medical costs and physician accountability for these expenses, you can't beat the cost - benefit ratio for the old fashioned rectal exam.