The rate of molecular evolution of alpha-fetoprotein approaches that of pseudogenes

We conducted the present study in an attempt to correlate function with the rate of molecular evolution for serum albumin and alpha-fetoprotein. We found a high rate of silent substitution (between 5 X 10(-9) and 7 X 10(-9)/site/year) for both the albumin and alpha-fetoprotein genes, perhaps the highest so far reported for an expressed nuclear gene. The rates of effective substitution and amino acid changes were also very high, but in contrast to silent substitutions, they are higher for alpha-fetoprotein than for albumin by approximately 70%. For alpha-fetoprotein, the rate of effective substitution (1.5 X 10(-9)/site/year) may be approaching that for nonfunctional pseudogenes (about 3 X 10(-9)/site/year). Evolutionary divergence was also estimated at the amino acid level. It was found that the rate of change of alpha-fetoprotein (55% amino acids replaced in 100 Myr) approaches that of the fastest-evolving fibrinopeptides (92% amino acids replaced in 100 Myr). This high rate may indicate that alpha-fetoprotein can tolerate a great deal of molecular variation without its function being impaired in the process. Albumin evolves at a slower rate (39% amino acids replaced in 100 Myr), although still faster than either hemoglobin (17% amino acids replaced in 100 Myr) or cytochrome c (5% amino acids replaced in 100 Myr). The slower evolutionary rate may indicate that albumin has more refined functional specifications and hence can tolerate fewer mutational changes. The latter conclusion remains, however, to be reconciled with the condition of inherited analbuminemia, where a virtually complete absence of albumin produces surprisingly few symptoms.