Human immune response to meningococcal outer membrane protein epitopes after natural infection or vaccination

Antibody levels in 41 sets of human acute- and convalescent-phase meningococcal sera were compared with those in 23 sets of human prevaccination and 2-week postvaccination sera. We used a modification of a solid-phase radioimmunoassay (SPRIA) technique to test each of the human serum samples as inhibitors of monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) that bind (HIMSPRIA) to the outer membrane complex from a 2a:P1.2:P5.1 strain. We used three murine MAbs specific for the 2a, P1.2, and P5.1 epitopes on meningococcal class 1, 2, and 5 proteins, respectively, to detect antibodies with similar specificities in human sera. Each of 40 available matching strains from patients were also screened with the three MAbs in a nitrocellulose spot blot assay. A total of 37 (92%) were positive for the 2a epitope, 36 (90%) were positive for the P1.2 epitope, and 16 (40%) were positive for the P5.1 epitope. Of 38 available convalescent-phase sera, 27 (71%) matched with these strains and had detectable inhibiting antibody for each of the MAb-defined protein epitopes of the infecting strain. Three convalescent-phase sera had no HIMSPRIA activity for MAb-defined epitopes that were present on the infecting strain; others had activity for one or two of the epitopes. The results were similar for pre- and postvaccination sera. The average level of HIMSPRIA activity for the P1.2 epitope was greater than fivefold higher in postvaccination sera compared with that in convalescent-phase sera. Sera with distinct patterns of HIMSPRIA activity also were tested by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and immunoblot analysis and showed a correlation between the HIMSPRIA activity for particular epitopes and the level of antibody binding to the immunoblotted proteins possessing those epitopes. A comparison of the HIMSPRIA and the bactericidal activity of selected postvaccination sera indicated a possible correlation between HIMSPRIA and bactericidal activity, but it also suggested the presence of bactericidal antibodies with specificities other than those defined by the MAbs.