Loss of ERβ expression in papillary thyroid carcinoma is associated with recurrence in young female

We investigated the expression of oestrogen receptors (ERs) in papillary thyroid cancers (PTCs) and evaluated their prognostic role.

We enrolled 81 female patients who underwent thyroid surgery and had a confirmed diagnosis of PTC between 01 January 1995 and 31 December 1996. Data on clinicopathologic parameters were obtained from patients' medical records. Tissue paraffin blocks of these 81 patients were collected for immunohistochemistry for ERα and ERβ.

ERα expression was observed in only eight patients (9·9%). In contrast, ERβ expression was positive in 36 (44·4%) patients. Total thyroidectomy (84·4% vs 61·1%, P = 0·017) and cervical lymph node metastasis (62·2% vs 22·2%, P = 0·000) were more frequent in the ERβ-negative group than in the ERβ-positive group. Among younger female patients (<45 years), the ERβ-negative group showed a tendency towards more frequent recurrent or persistent disease than the ERβ-positive group (42·3% vs 13·6%, P = 0·029). In contrast, the ERα-positive group showed more recurrent or persistent disease than the ERα-negative group in older female patients (100% vs 24·1%, P = 0·024). In multivariate analysis, ERβ negativity, extrathyroidal invasion and radioactive iodine treatment were risk factors for recurrence in young female patients.

Loss of ERβ expression was associated with recurrence in young female PTC patients. This finding suggests that oestrogen might play a protective role in the progression of PTC via ERβ, especially in young female patients.