Evolution of the major histocompatibility complex: independent origin of nonclassical class I genes in different...

The class I major histocompatibility complex genes are composed of classical and nonclassical genes, the latter being largely nonfunctional. To understand the evolutionary relationships of the two groups of class I genes, a phylogenetic analysis of DNA sequences was conducted using 45 genes from six mammalian and one avian species. The results indicate that nonclassical genes in one species are more closely related to classical genes from the same species than to nonclassical genes from a species belonging to a different order or family. This indicates that the differentiation of classical and nonclassical genes occurs rather rapidly in the genome. Classical genes are apparently duplicated with a high frequency in the evolutionary process, and many of the duplicated genes seem to degenerate into nonclassical genes as a result of deleterious mutation. The nonclassical Qa genes in the mouse have sequences homologous to regulatory sequences involved in the universal expression of classical class I genes, but they have accumulated numerous nucleotide substitutions in these sequences. The pattern of nucleotide substitution in nonclassical genes is different from that in classical genes. In nonclassical genes, the rate of nonsynonymous substitution is higher in the antigen recognition site than in other gene regions, as is true of classical genes. However, unlike the case of classical genes, the nonsynonymous rate does not always exceed the synonymous rate in the antigen recognition site. Nonclassical proteins further differ from classical proteins in having amino acid replacements in conserved antigen recognition site positions. These observations are consistent with the hypothesis that nonclassical genes have originated from classical genes but have lost classical class I function because of deleterious mutation.