Comparing lactate and glycerol as a single-electron donor for sulfate reduction in fluidized bed reactors

Among the greatest challenges to the full implementation of biological sulfate reduction are the cost and availability of the electron source. With the development of the biofuel industry, new organic substrates have become available. Therefore, this work sought to compare the performance of a sulfidogenic process utilizing either lactate or glycerol as the substrate for sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB) growth. Although sulfate reduction is energetically more favorable with lactate, glycerol is a less expensive alternative because excess production is forecasted with the worldwide development of the biodiesel industry. Continuous experiments were performed in a fluidized bed (FB) reactor containing activated carbon as a carrier for a mixed bacterial population composed of sulfate-reducing and fermentative bacteria. During the lactate-fed phases, incomplete oxidation of lactate to acetate by SRB was the dominant metabolic pathway resulting in as much as 90 % sulfate reduction and high acetate concentrations (2.7 g L(-1)). Conversely, in the glycerol-fed phases, glycerol degradation resulted from syntrophic cooperation between sulfate-reducing and fermentative bacteria that produce butyrate along with acetate (1.0 g L(-1)) as oxidation products. To our knowledge, this is the first report of butyrate formation during sulfate reduction in a glycerol-fed continuous-flow reactor. Sulfate concentrations were reduced by about 90 % (from 2,000 to 100-300 mg L(-1)) when glycerol was being fed to the reactor. Since the FB reactor was able to stand a change from lactate to glycerol, this reactor is recommended as the preferred option should glycerol be selected as a cost-effective alternative to lactate for continuous sulfate reduction.