Different biochemical properties explain why two equivalent Gα subunit mutants cause unrelated diseases

There is an increasing number of disease-associated Gα mutations identified from genome-wide sequencing campaigns or targeted efforts. Albright's Hereditary Osteodystrophy (AHO) was the first inherited disease associated with loss-of-function mutations in a G protein (Gαs) and other studies revealed gain-of-function Gα mutations in cancer. Here we attempted to solve the apparent quandary posed by the fact that the same mutation in two different G proteins appeared associated with both AHO and cancer. We first confirmed the presence of an inherited Gαs-R265H mutation from a previously described clinical case report of AHO. This mutation is structurally analogous to Gαo-R243H, an oncogenic mutant with increased activity in vitro and in cells due to rapid nucleotide exchange. We found that, contrary to Gαo-R243H, Gαs-R265H activity is compromised due to greatly impaired nucleotide binding in vitro and in cells. We obtained equivalent results when comparing another AHO mutation in Gαs (D173N) with a counterpart cancer mutation in Gαo (D151N). Gαo-R243H binds nucleotides efficiently under steady-state conditions but releases GDP much faster than the WT protein, suggesting diminished affinity for the nucleotide. These results indicate that the same disease-linked mutation in two different G proteins affects a common biochemical feature (nucleotide affinity) but to a different grade depending on the G protein (mild decrease for Gαo and severe for Gαs). We conclude that Gαs-R265H has dramatically impaired nucleotide affinity leading to the loss-of-function in AHO whereas Gαo-R243H has a mild decrease in nucleotide affinity that causes rapid nucleotide turnover and subsequent hyperactivity in cancer.