Disproportionate Contribution of Riparian Inputs to Organic Carbon Pools in Freshwater Systems

A lack of appropriate proxies has traditionally hampered our ability to distinguish riverine organic carbon (OC) sources at the landscape scale. However, the dissection of C₄ grasslands by C₃-enriched riparian vegetation, and the distinct carbon stable isotope signature (δ¹³C) of these two photosynthetic pathways, provides a unique setting to assess the relative contribution of riparian and more distant sources to riverine C pools. Here, we compared δ¹³C signatures of bulk sub-basin vegetation (δ¹³C_VEG) with those of riverine OC pools for a wide range of sites within two contrasting river basins in Madagascar. Although C₃-derived carbon dominated in the eastern Rianala catchment, consistent with the dominant vegetation, we found that in the C₄-dominated Betsiboka basin, riverine OC is disproportionately sourced from the C₃-enriched riparian fringe, irrespective of climatic season, even though δ¹³C_VEG estimates suggest as much as 96% of vegetation cover in some Betsiboka sub-basins may be accounted for by C₄ biomass. For example, δ¹³C values for river bed OC were on average 6.9 ± 2.7‰ depleted in ¹³C compared to paired estimates of δ¹³C_VEG. The disconnection of the wider C₄-dominated basin is considered the primary driver of the under-representation of C₄-derived C within riverine OC pools in the Betsiboka basin, although combustion of grassland biomass by fire is likely a subsidiary constraint on the quantity of terrestrial organic matter available for export to these streams and rivers. Our findings carry implications for the use of sedimentary δ¹³C signatures as proxies for past forest-grassland distribution and climate, as the C₄ component may be considerably underestimated due to its disconnection from riverine OC pools.