Direct reduction may need to be considered to avoid postoperative subtype P in patients with an unstable trochanteric...

It has recently been reported that the cases with an anterior femoral neck cortex posterior to the distal fragment (subtype P) in the lateral view of a postoperative radiograph have a risk of excessive sliding of lag screws compared to those located anterior to the distal fragment (subtype A) or perfectly continuous to the distal fragment (subtype N) following osteosynthesis for the treatment of a trochanteric fracture. The purpose of this study was to investigate factors that influence the postoperative subtype in the lateral view of radiographs.

This study reviewed 136 patients who underwent osteosynthesis using an intramedullary hip nail for the treatment of a trochanteric fracture. A closed reduction was performed in 130 patients (95.6 %), while a direct reduction via a small elevator with a small skin incision was performed in the other six patients (4.4 %). The 136 patients were divided into two groups (subtype P and subtype A or N) based on postoperative radiographs taken of the lateral view. Both clinical and radiological factors were analyzed using the univariate and multivariable analyses.

Thirty-nine patients (29 %) were categorized as subtype P and 97 patients (71 %) were categorized as subtype A or N. A multivariate analysis demonstrated that unstable fractures were associated with a significant risk of postoperative subtype P (Odds ratio: 24.45, P = 0.0024).

The results of this study suggest that direct reduction via a small elevator with a small skin incision or percutaneous intrafocal pinning may be needed in these cases.