An Experimental Study of Particulate Bone Graft for Secondary Inlay Cranioplasty Over Scarred Dura

Inlay cranioplasty in children is challenging because autologous bone is limited. Cranial particulate bone graft effectively closes defects when placed over normal dura. The purpose of this study was to determine if particulate bone graft will ossify when used for secondary cranioplasty over scarred dura.

A 17 × 17-mm critical-sized defect was made in the parietal bone of 16 rabbits. Four animals had no implant (group 1). Twelve animals had the defect remade 16 weeks postoperatively, which was managed in 2 ways: group 2 (no implant; n = 6) and group 4 (particulate bone graft; n = 6). Particulate graft was obtained using a brace and bit from the frontal bone. Computed tomography was used to determine the area of ossification and thickness of the healed graft. Eight animals previously managed with particulate bone graft over normal dura were used as an additional control (group 3).

Critical-sized defects filled with particulate bone graft over scarred dura (group 4) exhibited superior healing of the area (83.8%; range, 73.0%-90.6%) compared to control defects over normal dura (group 1: 62.9%; range, 56.5%-73.4%) or scarred dura (group 2: 56.9%; range, 40.0%-68.3%) (P = 0.0004). Particulate bone on scarred dura exhibited less ossified area (P = 0.002), and thinner bone (0.95 mm, range, 0.71-1.32 mm) compared to defects in which graft was placed over normal dura (group 3: area, 99.2%; range, 96.8%-100%; thickness, 1.9 mm, range; 1.1-3.1 mm) (P = 0.04).

Particulate bone graft ossifies inlay cranial defects over scarred dura although inferior to placement over normal dura. Clinically, particulate bone graft may be used for secondary inlay cranioplasty.