The ancient heart of the ribosomal large subunit: a response to Caetano-Anolles

Our recent Accretion Model of ribosomal evolution uses insertion fingerprints and a "trunk-branch" formalism to recapitulate the building up of common core rRNA of the Large Ribosomal Subunit. The Accretion Model is a conservative and natural extension of a method developed by Bokov and Steinberg (Nature 457:977-80, 2009), which confirms the correctness of lower resolution models by Fox and others. In each of these models, the LSU originates with the peptidyl transferase center (PTC), consistent with expectations that the ribosome is the source of defined-sequence functional proteins. In an adjacent note, Caetano-Anolles (J Mol Evol 80:162-165, 2015) disparages the Accretion Model, because it controverts the 'Growth Inferred by Genothermal Ordering' (GIGO) model. GIGO analyzes secondary structures, assigns the origin of the ribosome to a region outside of the PTC, and assumes or deduces that (i) large protein enzymes of defined amino acid sequence predate ribosomal synthesis of proteins, (ii) proteins directly replicate by non-ribosomal mechanisms, (iii) rRNA unfailingly increases in thermodynamic stability over time, and (iv) the Woese and Fox canonical tree of life is mis-rooted. Much of the specific GIGO critique of the Accretion Model is based on confusion about the three-dimensional nature of RNA and trunk-branch polymorphism; the Accretion Model incorporates several types of trunk-branch relationships.