[Evaluation of a Micro-Manipulator for Middle Ear Surgery: A Preclinical Trial]

Microsurgical preparation is limited by geometric and mechanical constraints. In preparation for clinical use, this study investigates performance, ease of handling and precision of a novel manipulator concept for microsurgery.

A group of 15 ENT experienced doctors, as well as a group of 17 medical students with low/non surgical experience participated in the study. Each of the subjects carried out 4 trials of simulated surgeries on a phantom with built-in force sensors. The task was to apply a defined force between 1.5 and 2 N using a Fisch micro perforator, 16 cm length, 0.4 mm (Storz) targeting holes with a diameter of 0.5 mm. For comparison, the Fisch micro perforator was moved manually or with the manipulator.

Assessing the total number of errors proved a significantly lower error number (p<0.0001) and an improvement of the accuracy of 76% with the manipulator. The time requirement for the procedure with the micro manipulator is on average 2-3 times higher than with manual control (p<0.0001). But it is notable that this time requirement significantly decreases with training (p<0.0001).

The study shows a significant reduction in the number of errors by using a new manipulator concept compared to the non-augmented human hand in an experimental setup. We observed a significant learning effect when subjects applied the micro manipulator, resulting in reduction of the time requirement while maintaining a constant number of errors.