Comparison of International Reference Values for Bone Speed of Sound in Pediatric Populations: Meta-analysis

R Rivas-Ruiz1, L Méndez-Sánchez2, O D Castelán-Martínez3

  • 1Centro de Adiestramiento en Investigación Clínica, Coordinación de Investigación en Salud, Centro Médico Nacional S. XXI, IMSS, México, D.F.; Facultad de Medicina, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, México, D.F.

Insights

International reference values for speed of sound (SoS) in children vary by country. Quantitative ultrasound (QUS) data revealed significant differences in pediatric SoS, particularly for Mexico compared to other nations.

Area of Science:

  • Pediatric Bone Health
  • Quantitative Ultrasound (QUS)
  • International Reference Values

Background:

  • Quantitative ultrasound (QUS) is a non-invasive method to assess bone health.
  • Establishing reliable international reference values (RV) for speed of sound (SoS) in pediatric populations is crucial for accurate bone assessment.
  • Variations in QUS-derived SoS-RV may exist across different countries.

Purpose of the Study:

  • To systematically compare international reference values (RV) for tibial and radial speed of sound (SoS) in pediatric populations.
  • To identify potential differences in SoS-RV based on country of origin using quantitative ultrasound (QUS).
  • To analyze these variations by age and geographical location.

Main Methods:

  • Systematic review and meta-analysis of published studies utilizing QUS (Sunlight Omnisense) in pediatric populations.
  • Inclusion of nine studies encompassing 6963 patients, with specific focus on newborn and pediatric age groups.
  • Comparative analysis of SoS-RV between different countries, including Italy, Portugal, Israel, Canada, Mexico, Greece, and Turkey.

Main Results:

  • For newborns (27-42 wk gestational age), significant differences in SoS-RV were found between Portugal and Israel, but not between Italy-Portugal or Italy-Israel.
  • In pediatric populations, significant differences in SoS-RV were observed between Mexico and Israel, Portugal, Greece, Turkey, and Canada.
  • No significant differences in SoS-RV were found between Israel and Turkey, Greece, or Canada.

Conclusions:

  • Tibial and radial SoS-RV obtained by QUS show significant international variations in pediatric populations.
  • Mexico exhibits notably different SoS-RV compared to several other countries, highlighting the need for country-specific reference data.
  • These findings underscore the importance of considering geographical origin when interpreting QUS-derived SoS values in children.

Related Concept Videos

Speed of Sound in Solids and Liquids00:51

Speed of Sound in Solids and Liquids

Most solids and liquids are incompressible—their densities remain constant throughout. In the presence of an external force, the molecules tend to restore to their original positions, which is only possible because the constituents interact. The interactions help the constituents pass on information about external disturbances, like sound waves. Therefore, sound waves travel faster through these media. Compared to solids, the constituents in a liquid are less tightly bound. Thus, sound...
4.1K
Deriving the Speed of Sound in a Liquid01:09

Deriving the Speed of Sound in a Liquid

As with waves on a string, the speed of sound or a mechanical wave in a fluid depends on the fluid's elastic modulus and inertia. The two relevant physical quantities are the bulk modulus and the density of the material. Indeed, it turns out that the relationship between speed and the bulk modulus and density in fluids is the same as that between the speed and the Young's modulus and density in solids.
The speed of sound in fluids can be derived by considering a mechanical wave...
1.1K
Speed of Sound in Gases01:08

Speed of Sound in Gases

The speed of sound in a gaseous medium depends on various factors. Since gases constitute molecules that are free to move, they are highly compressible. Hence, sound waves travel slowly through gases. Thermodynamics helps us understand the relationship between pressure, volume, and temperature of gases, thus, the speed of sound in an ideal gas can be determined using the laws of thermodynamics. At the same time, Newton's laws of motion and the continuity equation of fluid dynamics also come...
4.3K