Unclear Implications: Commentary on Norton and Ariely (2011)
1Department of Philosophy, Yale University, New Haven, CT shelly.kagan@yale.edu.
Summary
Norton and Ariely's empirical findings suggest significant insights, but their broader moral and political implications remain ambiguous. Further analysis is needed to clarify the consequences of their research.
Area of Science:
- Behavioral Economics
- Moral Philosophy
- Political Science
Background:
- Norton and Ariely's research explores the empirical basis of human behavior.
- Existing studies offer suggestive findings but lack clear moral and political interpretations.
Purpose of the Study:
- To critically evaluate the moral and political implications of Norton and Ariely's empirical findings.
- To argue for the ambiguity surrounding the broader consequences of their work.
Main Methods:
- Critical analysis of existing empirical research.
- Philosophical and political interpretation of research outcomes.
Main Results:
- The empirical findings presented by Norton and Ariely are suggestive.
- The moral and political implications derived from these findings are currently unclear.
Conclusions:
- The ambiguity of the implications necessitates further scholarly discussion.
- Clarification of the moral and political ramifications is crucial for understanding the research's impact.
Related Concept Videos
00:52Social Proof
32.6K
Social proof is a form of persuasion based on comparison and conformity. People compare their behavior and actions to what others are doing and will change to conform to do what their peers do.
32.6K
00:56Attribution Theory
14.0K
Behavior is a product of both the situation (e.g., cultural influences, social roles, and the presence of bystanders) and of the person (e.g., personality characteristics). Subfields of psychology tend to focus on one influence or behavior over others. Situationism is the view that our behavior and actions are determined by our immediate environment and surroundings. In contrast, dispositionism holds that our behavior is determined by internal factors (Heider, 1958).
14.0K
01:29Theory of Attribution II: Kelley's Covariation Theory
953
Attribution theory plays a crucial role in social psychology, helping to explain how individuals interpret the causes of behavior. One prominent model within this field is Harold Kelley's covariation theory, which provides a systematic approach to determining whether internal traits or external circumstances drive a person's actions. The model posits that individuals rely on three key types of information—consensus, consistency, and distinctiveness—to make these judgments.Consensus:...
953
01:20Lazarus's Cognitive Appraisal Theory
2.7K
Cognitive psychologist Richard Lazarus proposed the cognitive-mediational theory of emotions, which emphasizes how individuals' assessments of stressors significantly affect their experience of stress. According to Lazarus, the stress response is determined by a two-step appraisal process: primary appraisal and secondary appraisal. These cognitive appraisals help individuals evaluate the potential impact of a stressor and determine the adequacy of their coping resources.
Primary Appraisal:...
Primary Appraisal:...
2.7K
02:05Self-Presentation: Self-Monitoring and Self-Handicapping
45.2K
People can go to great lengths to protect their self-image and present themselves in ways that they want others to see them. Sociologist Erving Goffman presented the idea that a person is like an actor on a stage. Calling his theory dramaturgy, Goffman believed that we use “impression management” to present ourselves to others as we hope to be perceived. Each situation is a new scene, and individuals perform different roles depending on who is present (Goffman, 1959). Think about...
45.2K
01:15Theory of Attribution I: Correspondent Inference Theory
905
Correspondent inference theory, proposed by Jones and Davis in 1965, seeks to explain how individuals infer stable personality traits from observed behaviors. It suggests that people attribute actions to underlying dispositions rather than external circumstances, particularly when the behavior appears intentional and socially significant.Voluntary Behavior and Dispositional AttributionAccording to this theory, individuals are more likely to attribute behavior to personal traits when it appears...
905