Critical Anomalies of Two SN1 Hydrolysis Reactions in Critical Binary Solutions

Rates of SN1 hydrolysis reactions for 2-chloro-2-methylbutane in the critical solution of isobutyric acid + water and for 2-bromo-2-methylpropane in the critical solution of triethylamine + water in the one-phase region and at various temperatures have been determined respectively by conductance measurements. It was found that the reaction rates at different temperatures for those two SN1 reactions were well described by the Arrhenius equation in the noncritical region, whereas near the critical points the critical slowing down was clearly detected. These results are inconsistent with a previous report in the literature (J. Phys. Chem. A 2003, 107, 8435 - 8443). Reanalyzing the literature data, we found that if an Arrhenius equation appropriate to either the one-phase region or the two-phase region being examined was used as the background, a critical slowing down rather than a speeding up was detected for the reaction in both the one-phase region and the two-phase region. The experimental data from different sources were fitted with a simplified crossover formalism characterizing the critical effect on the reactions to determine the critical slowing down exponents, which were found to be about 0.04, showing that only a dynamic critical slowing down could be detected for these reaction systems. This phenomenon was attributed to the fact that the SN1 hydrolysis reaction is neither a first-order nor a pseudo-first-order reaction in the reverse direction and the kinetic measurements were carried out in a region quite far from the equilibrium of the reactions.