Comparative effects of pilocarpine in different vehicles on pupil diameter in albino rabbits and squirrel monkeys

Several commercial pilocarpine preparations have been compared for their efficacy of drug delivery as evaluated by changes in pupil diameter, and return to base-line pupil size, in rabbits and squirrel monkeys. Adsorbocarpine, Isoptocarpine, Pilocar, all at 2%, and Pilopine HS gel, 4%, were used. In albino rabbits the order of efficacy, as judged by area under the curve, or maximal pupil diameter change, was Pilopine greater than Isoptocarpine = Adsorbocarpine greater than Pilocar = saline (prepared in this laboratory). In general, greater areas under the curve were associated with greater changes in pupil diameter. Pupil diameter had returned to normal by a maximum of 5 hours after drop instillation. In squirrel monkeys, the maximum pupillary change was statistically (P greater than 0.05) the same for all preparations, as was the percentage change in pupil diameter at 6 hours since pupils were still somewhat constricted at this time after drop instillation. The differences in area under the curve were minor. The greater response in primates compared to rabbits may be due to differences in pigment, intraocular kinetics and a far more active ciliary muscle in primates. Also studied were newly developed, non-surfactant containing, preservative-free polymer- and microparticle-based vehicles. Some of the vehicles, based on cyanoacrylate, modified hyaluronate, anionic copolymers, polyvinyl-pyrrolidone, cross-linked gelatin and microparticles showed greater pupillary changes and areas under the curve in rabbits compared to saline vehicle. When compared to commercial preparations in the monkey eye cyanoacrylate block copolymer and modified hyaluronate showed an increase in efficacy. Polyvinylpyrrolidone, anionic copolymer and cross-linked gelatin were equal to the commercial preparations.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)