Simple design of slanted grating with simplified modal method: comment
Related Experiment Video
Updated: Mar 31, 2026

Measurement of Chladni Mode Shapes with an Optical Lever Method
Published on: June 5, 2020
Abstract:
In the recent Letter [Opt. Lett.39, 781 (2014)10.1364/OL.39.000781OPLEDP0146-9592] that proposes a method to design slanted parallelogram gratings based on the simplified modal method, the analysis of the modal field in the grating layer is incorrect; therefore, the validity of the equivalence between slanted parallelogram gratings and upright rectangular gratings that the authors thereby have deduced is questionable or at least in need of substantial modifications.
More Related Videos
Related Concept Videos
Design of Prismatic Beams for Bending
Prismatic Beams: Problem Solving
The design begins with analyzing the beam as a free body to identify moments and force balances, thereby determining support reactions. Next, the...
Beams with Symmetric Loadings
The M/EI...
Design Example: Aggregate Gradation
The grading, or particle-size distribution, of sand is determined using sieve analysis, with standard sizes ranging from 150 μm to 10 mm (ASTM No. 100 sieve to 3⁄8 in. sieve). Sand is...
Shear and Bending Moment Diagram: Problem Solving
Draw a Free-Body Diagram: Start by drawing a free-body diagram of the entire beam, including the concentrated loads, distributed load, and reaction...
Design Example: Forces in Sluice Gate
Key variables in...

