Snippets From the Past: Imaginative Designs--Separating Hereditary From Environmental Effects in pre-DNA Times

In an attempt to reproduce the results of an inconclusive 1927 report by the British Medical Research Council on the hereditary versus social origins of rheumatic fever, Read, Ciocco, and Taussig, from Johns Hopkins University, with the support of Frost, conducted a case-control study in 1935 and 1936. Their study, which appeared in the American Journal of Hygiene in 1938, was outstanding for its clear and tidy rationale for separating hereditary from environmental causes. The authors compared the prevalence of rheumatic fever among the relatives of 33 children admitted for "incident" rheumatic fever and 33 control children admitted in a tuberculosis clinic for reasons other than rheumatic fever. Both rheumatic fever (cases) and tuberculosis (controls) were diseases of the poor. All family members of both cases and controls, including uncles, aunts, and grandparents, were eligible for interview and physical examination. The results were compatible with the presence of an "inherited predisposition" to rheumatic fever because the disease was more prevalent among the uncles, aunts, and grandparents of case patients than among those of control patients. Methodologically, the paper by Read, Ciocco, and Taussig is an important but almost completely forgotten milestone in the evolution of case-control studies and of genetic epidemiology.