Impact of a Palliative Care Program on Tracheostomy Utilization in a Community Hospital

Tracheostomies are typically provided to wean patients off the ventilator. However, in many circumstances tracheostomies are placed in patients who are at the end of their life with little hope of meaningful recovery. Palliative care teams decrease utilization of aggressive medical interventions in patients who are at the end of life.

The study objective was to determine the impact of a palliative care team on tracheostomy utilization in a community hospital setting.

The study was a four-year retrospective analysis of adult patients undergoing elective tracheostomy two years before and after the establishment of a palliative care program. The study in an ethnically diverse community hospital included patients older than 18 years old, with patients undergoing a tracheostomy due to trauma excluded. Before and after comparisons were made of demographics, in-hospital mortality, length of stay, and discharge status of patients undergoing tracheostomy.

Seven hundred ninety patients undergoing tracheostomy were identified (n = 406, n = 384 before and after September 10, 2010, respectively). Patients were ethnically diverse (Caucasian 43%, Asian 23%, African American 11%, Hispanic 7%). The number of hospital admissions slightly increased during these two time periods (n = 58,926; n = 60,662, respectively). There were no statistical differences in age (73 versus 72, p = 0.827); gender (n = 218 [54%] versus n = 217 [57%] male, p = 0.426); or race (n = 187 [46%] versus n = 150 [39%] Caucasian, p = 0.073) in the two time periods. Patients who underwent tracheostomy after a palliative care service was established had less incidence of comorbid disease (Charlson Comorbidity Index score [CCIS]: 2 versus 3, p = 0.025); lower inpatient mortality (n = 107 [28%] versus n = 148 [37%], p = 0.009]); greater discharge to home or rehabilitation (n = 262 [68%] versus n = 249 [62%], p = 0.01); and lower rates of palliative weaning from mechanical ventilation (n = 61[16%] versus n = 113 [28%], p < 0.001).

In an ethnically diverse community hospital, the institution of a palliative care program appears to have improved patient selection for tracheostomy with lower rates of inpatient mortality, improved rates of home discharge, and lower rates of palliative weaning from mechanical ventilation.