Surveillance and Radiation Therapy for Stage I Seminoma--Have We Learned From the Evidence?

To analyze, in the setting of stage I seminoma, the factors affecting adjuvant treatment decisions and resulting survival outcomes, using a national dataset.

We identified 33,094 stage I seminoma patients after orchiectomy from 1998 to 2012 from the National Cancer Data Base. Factors affecting treatment selection (active surveillance [AS] vs adjuvant treatment [AT]) were identified using a parsimonious multivariate logistic regression model. Propensity scores for treatment decision were generated and incorporated into a multivariate Cox regression analysis of overall survival. This process was then repeated within the AT cohort for factors predictive for chemotherapy [CT] versus radiation therapy [RT].

Only 33% of patients received AS, and 65% received AT (89% RT and 11% CT). From 1998 to 2012 the proportion receiving AS increased from 23% to 60%, whereas RT utilization decreased from 73% to 21%, and CT utilization increased from 2% to 17%. Utilization of low-dose RT increased from 1.5% in 1999 to 34% in 2012. There was a small absolute overall survival advantage to AT over AS at 10 years (95.0% vs 93.4%, propensity adjusted hazard ratio 0.58, P<.0005).

There has been a significant increase in use of AS for stage I seminoma, influenced by both sociodemogrpahic and clinicopathologic factors. Between AT options, there has been significant increase in use of CT, mirrored by a decline in use of RT. Although overall survival remains high for all 3 treatment strategies, AT seems to be associated with a small absolute survival advantage over AS up to 10 years out from diagnosis.