Partitioning of exchangeable fluorescent phospholipids and sphingolipids between different lipid bilayer environments

Exchangeable phospho- and sphingolipid probes (phosphatidylcholine, -ethanolamine, -serine, and -glycerol, phosphatidic acid, sphingomyelin, cerebroside, and sulfatide) have been synthesized in which one acyl chain is substituted with a fluorescent bimanyl, 7-(dimethylamino)coumarin-3-yl, or diphenyl-hexatrienyl group. The distribution of these probes between two different populations of lipid vesicles can be readily monitored by fluorescence intensity measurements, as described by Nichols and Pagano [Nichols, J. W., & Pagano, R. E. (1982) Biochemistry 21, 1720-1726], when one of the vesicle populations contains a low mole fraction of a nonexchangeable quencher, (12-DABS)-18-PC. The probes examined in this study exchange between phospholipid vesicles on a time scale of minutes, with kinetics indicating that the transfer process takes place by diffusion of probe monomers through the aqueous phase. As expected, lipid probes with different charges differ markedly in their equilibrium distributions between neutral and charged lipid vesicles. However, probes with different polar headgroups differ only modestly in their relative affinities for vesicles composed of "hydrogen-bonding" lipids (PE and PS) vs "non-hydrogen-bonding" lipids (PC and PG or O-methyl-PA). Probes with different headgroups also show modest, albeit reproducible, differences in their relative affinities for cholesterol-containing vs cholesterol-free PC/PG vesicles. Our results suggest that lipids with different headgroup structures may mix more nearly ideally in liquid-crystalline lipid bilayers than would be predicted from previous analyses of the phase diagrams for binary lipid mixtures.