Spacers versus nebulizers in treatment of acute asthma - a prospective randomized study in preschool children

To compare administration of bronchodilators by nebulizers with delivery by metered dose inhalers (MDIs) with spacers and to evaluate the clinical effect of the treatment of acute asthma in preschool children.

A prospective randomized clinical trial in a pediatric emergency department (PED). Preschool children who were admitted for virus induced wheezing or acute asthma exacerbation were randomly allocated to receive bronchodilator treatment by nebulizer or by metered dose inhaler. The accompanying parents completed a questionnaire.

The length of stay in the PED and the hospitalization rate were similar and no difference was seen in the parents' view of ease of use and device acceptance. Baseline data were similar for both groups apart from the family history of asthma and atopic disease that was greater in the nebulizer group. No significant differences were seen in heart rate, respiratory rate and oxygen saturation at baseline and after the treatment. According to the parents 40% of the participants had asthma diagnosis though up to 66% had some kind of asthma medication.

Our data suggests that MDIs with spacers are at least as effective as nebulizers in the delivery of beta agonists to treat preschool children with virus induced wheezing or acute exacerbations of asthma in the PED. Parents may underestimate the gravity of their children's asthma. It is mandatory to provide adequate information to the staff and parents in order to treat pediatric acute asthma successfully.