A comparison of heat exchangers for blood cardioplegia

During open heart surgery, myocardial protection provided by oxygenated blood-based cardioplegia is superior to that provided by non-oxygenated crystalloid cardioplegia. However, the widespread use of blood cardioplegia has been limited by the cost and complexity of the associated cooling and delivery systems. The performance of a simple system--a polyethylene coil immersed in ice--has been compared with three systems incorporating specialized, water-jacketed heat exchangers: Buckberg Shiley, Shiley BCD and Bentley HE-100. Blood was diluted to a haematocrit of 22% and delivered to each cooling system at flow rates of 200-500 mL/min and temperatures of 25 degrees C and 30 degrees C. Cooling water at 0-1 degree C was supplied to the heat exchangers at flow rates of 2, 4, and 6 L/min. Performance was measured by comparing the blood outflow temperatures at the same inflow temperature under a variety of test conditions which simulated those occurring in clinical practice. All cooling systems, except the Buckberg Shiley, were able consistently to cool blood cardioplegia adequately (below 10 degrees C), but the ice coil was the most effective. The heat exchanger systems are 3-4 times more expensive than the ice coil and require an external source of cold water. Thus the ice coil system has the advantages of simplicity, efficiency, and economy.