Scar Detection by Pulse-Cancellation Echocardiography: Validation by CMR in Patients With Recent STEMI

This study sought to assess an echocardiographic approach (scar imaging echocardiography with ultrasound multipulse scheme [eSCAR]), based on existing multipulse ultrasound scheme, as a marker of myocardial scar in humans, compared with cardiac magnetic resonance assessing late gadolinium enhancement (CMR-LGE).

The detection of myocardial scar impacts patient prognosis and management in coronary artery disease and other types of cardiac disease. The clinical experience with echocardiography suggests that the reflected ultrasound signal is often significantly enhanced in infarcted myocardial segments.

Twenty patients with a recent ST-segment elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI) (cases) and 15 patients with absent CMR-LGE (negative controls) were imaged with both the eSCAR pulse-cancellation echocardiography and CMR-LGE to assess their potential association.

Scar was detectable at CMR-LGE in 19 of 20 STEMI patients (91%), whereas all (100%) demonstrated eSCAR at echocardiography. In the 19 STEMI patients in whom CMR-LGE was detected, regional matching between eSCAR and CMR-LGE was total, although the segmental extent of detected scar was not always superimposable, particularly in the most apical segments, a region in which eSCAR demonstrated undersensitivity for the true extent of scar.

A 2-dimensional multipulse echocardiography allows detection of myocardial scar, reliably matching the presence and site of CMR-LGE at 30 days after STEMI, or its absence in negative controls.