HARTMANN'S PROCEDURE REVISITED

R P Choubey1, P K Patnaik1, A K Sharma2

  • 1Classified Specialist Surgery & Gastrointestinal Surgery, Command Hospital, (Central Command) Lucknow.

Insights

Hartmann's procedure is a safe and effective surgical option for colorectal pathologies. Reestablishing bowel continuity in a second stage significantly reduces complications and mortality.

Area of Science:

  • Colorectal Surgery
  • Surgical Outcomes
  • Gastrointestinal Procedures

Background:

  • Hartmann's procedure is utilized for various colorectal conditions.
  • Assessing the safety and efficacy of Hartmann's procedure is crucial for patient outcomes.
  • Previous literature suggests potential risks associated with primary anastomosis in certain colorectal surgeries.

Purpose of the Study:

  • To evaluate the utility, safety, and effectiveness of Hartmann's procedure in patients undergoing colonic surgery.
  • To compare complication and mortality rates between the initial Hartmann's procedure and subsequent reversal surgery.

Main Methods:

  • Retrospective analysis of 63 patients who underwent Hartmann's procedure between July 1991 and June 1999.
  • Data collected included patient demographics, surgical outcomes, mortality, and complication rates.
  • Comparison of outcomes for the initial procedure versus the second stage (reestablishing bowel continuity).

Main Results:

  • The overall mortality for the initial Hartmann's procedure was 12.7%.
  • In 47 patients where bowel continuity was reestablished in a second stage, mortality was nil.
  • Complication rates were significantly lower in the second stage operation compared to the first.

Conclusions:

  • Hartmann's procedure is a safe and effective surgical approach for managing colorectal pathologies.
  • Resection and primary anastomosis in certain colorectal conditions carry higher risks.
  • Staged approach with Hartmann's procedure followed by reversal offers improved safety and reduced complications.