Voltammetric Ion Selectivity of Thin Ionophore-Based Polymeric Membranes: Kinetic Effect of Ion Hydrophilicity

The high ion selectivity of potentiometric and optical sensors based on ionophore-based polymeric membranes is thermodynamically limited. Here, we report that the voltammetric selectivity of thin ionophore-based polymeric membranes can be kinetically improved by several orders of magnitude in comparison with their thermodynamic selectivity. The kinetic improvement of voltammetric selectivity is evaluated quantitatively by newly introducing a voltammetric selectivity coefficient in addition to a thermodynamic selectivity coefficient. Experimentally, both voltammetric and thermodynamic selectivity coefficients are determined from cyclic voltammograms of excess amounts of analyte and interfering ions with respect to the amount of a Na(+)- or Li(+)-selective ionophore in thin polymeric membranes. We reveal the slower ionophore-facilitated transfer of a smaller alkaline earth metal cation with higher hydrophilicity across the membrane/water interface, thereby kinetically improving voltammetric Na(+) selectivity against calcium, strontium, and barium ions by 3, 2, and 1 order of magnitude, respectively, in separate solutions. Remarkably, voltammetric Na(+) and Li(+) selectivity against calcium and magnesium ions in mixed solutions is improved by 4 and >7 orders of magnitude, respectively, owing to both thermodynamic and kinetic effects in comparison with thermodynamic selectivity in separate solutions. Advantageously, the simultaneous detection of sodium and calcium ions is enabled voltammetrically in contrast to the potentiometric and optical counterparts. Mechanistically, we propose a new hypothetical model that the slower transfer of a more hydrophilic ion is controlled by its partial dehydration during the formation of the adduct with a "water finger" prior to complexation with an ionophore at the membrane/water interface.