Related Experiment Video
Updated: Mar 15, 2026

Patient-Specific Polyvinyl Alcohol Phantom Fabrication with Ultrasound and X-Ray Contrast for Brain Tumor Surgery Planning
Published on: July 14, 2020
Technical Note: Development of a 3D printed subresolution sandwich phantom for validation of brain SPECT analysis
Ian S Negus1, Robin B Holmes1, Kirsty C Jordan2
1Department of Medical Physics and Bioengineering, University Hospitals Bristol NHS Foundation Trust, Bristol BS28HW, United Kingdom.
Researchers developed a new, head-shaped 3D printed tool to improve the accuracy of brain SPECT scans. By using specialized plastic slabs and printed radioactive paper, they created a realistic model that helps calibrate scanners and refine image analysis. This approach reduces errors compared to older, simpler designs and can be adapted for other types of medical imaging.
Area of Science:
- Medical imaging physics and subresolution sandwich phantom validation
- Neurological diagnostic instrumentation within nuclear medicine
Background:
Current clinical brain imaging often relies on generic cylindrical models that fail to capture complex anatomical structures accurately. This limitation creates significant challenges when attempting to standardize scanner performance across different healthcare facilities. No prior work had resolved the need for a patient-specific, adaptable tool that mimics actual brain tissue density. That uncertainty drove the development of new manufacturing techniques for medical phantoms. Prior research has shown that inaccurate attenuation correction leads to substantial errors in diagnostic interpretation. This gap motivated the creation of a more realistic, head-shaped testing device. Previous methods lacked the ability to simulate the detailed distribution of radioactive tracers found in real patients. Researchers required a solution that could integrate anatomical data directly into the calibration process.
Purpose Of The Study:
The primary aim was to develop an adaptable, head-shaped radionuclide phantom to simulate molecular imaging of the brain. This project sought to improve the accuracy of clinical image analysis protocols. The researchers intended to create a tool that allows for the characterization and correction of scanner-specific performance issues. This effort was motivated by the need to integrate databases of normal subjects into routine diagnostic workflows. The team addressed the limitations of existing cylindrical designs that do not reflect human anatomy. They aimed to provide a more realistic testing environment for clinical acquisition and reconstruction procedures. This development helps standardize the evaluation of neurological scans across different medical facilities. The study focused on creating a physically accurate model that remains compatible with standard gamma camera technology.
Main Methods:
The team employed a fused deposition modeling printer to fabricate transaxial slabs from simulated magnetic resonance imaging data. They adjusted the fill ratio of the polylactide filament to replicate the attenuation characteristics of human brain tissue. Transmission scans verified the density of these printed components before final assembly. Radioactive tracer distribution was achieved by printing images of gray and white matter onto paper using a standard ink cartridge filled with technetium-99m pertechnetate. The researchers then layered these radioactive sheets between the plastic slabs to form the complete model. A dual-headed gamma camera captured the final assembly to simulate a clinical hexamethylpropylene amine oxime scan. Automated ellipse fitting algorithms processed the resulting data to apply necessary attenuation corrections. This systematic approach replaced manual registration techniques to ensure consistent image analysis.
Main Results:
The researchers successfully demonstrated that their new device produces images comparable to those from existing elliptical polymethyl methacrylate phantoms. Visual assessments and count profiles confirmed the high degree of similarity between the two testing methods. The automated ellipse fitting process effectively removed the variability inherent in manual attenuation correction. This improvement ensures more reliable results when applying databases of normal subjects to clinical scans. The team confirmed that the printed polylactide density accurately matched the attenuation of brain tissue. Transmission measurements validated the physical properties of the slabs throughout the construction process. The study showed that the sandwich design provides a realistic simulation of HMPAO SPECT imaging. These results indicate that the method is suitable for validating a wide range of neurological imaging applications.
Conclusions:
The authors propose that their novel device successfully mimics realistic brain imaging conditions for clinical evaluation. This synthesis suggests that using custom-printed slabs improves the consistency of attenuation correction procedures. The study implies that replacing manual alignment with automated fitting reduces operator-dependent variability in diagnostic outputs. Researchers indicate that the current design provides a reliable benchmark for validating neurological imaging protocols. The findings suggest that this methodology could be adapted for other modalities beyond single-photon emission computed tomography. The authors note that thinner construction materials might allow for future application in positron emission tomography. This work highlights the potential for additive manufacturing to enhance the precision of medical diagnostic tools. The team concludes that their approach offers a robust framework for improving the quality of patient scans.
Frequently Asked Questions
The researchers utilize a sandwich design, alternating 3D-printed polylactide slabs with radioactive paper sheets. This configuration allows for the precise simulation of gray and white matter tracer distribution, which is not possible with traditional cylindrical models.
The team employs fused deposition modeling to construct the head-shaped device. This additive manufacturing technique enables the precise control of the fill ratio, which adjusts the plastic density to match brain tissue attenuation.
The authors emphasize that automated ellipse fitting is necessary to standardize attenuation correction. This technical step eliminates the variability caused by manual registration, which is a common limitation in older, non-anatomical phantom designs.
The researchers use segmented magnetic resonance imaging data to derive the physical shape and internal anatomy. This data ensures that the phantom accurately represents the spatial characteristics of a human head during the scanning procedure.
The team measures the Hounsfield unit on computed tomography scans to verify the material density. This measurement confirms that the printed polylactide matches the attenuation properties of actual brain tissue.
The authors suggest that modifying the slab thickness could enable the use of this phantom for positron emission tomography. This potential expansion demonstrates the versatility of the design compared to existing elliptical polymethyl methacrylate models.

